Understanding Credit Card Processing Fees
Credit card processing fees are one of the largest expenses for many businesses—yet most business owners don't fully understand what they're paying or why. This guide breaks down exactly how fees work so you can make informed decisions.
The Three Components of Processing Fees
Every card transaction involves three fee components:
1. Interchange Fees (Largest Portion)
Interchange is set by the card networks (Visa, Mastercard) and paid to the bank that issued the customer's card. This is typically 1.5% to 2.5% of the transaction.
Key facts about interchange:
- Set by card networks, not your processor
- Varies by card type (rewards cards cost more)
- Varies by transaction type (in-person is cheaper)
- Published publicly—same for everyone
- Updates twice per year (April and October)
2. Assessment Fees (Smallest Portion)
Assessment fees are paid to the card networks themselves (Visa, Mastercard, Amex, Discover). Typically 0.13% to 0.15% per transaction.
- Also non-negotiable
- Same for all merchants
- Much smaller than interchange
3. Processor Markup (The Negotiable Part)
This is what your payment processor charges for their services—routing transactions, providing equipment, support, reporting, etc.
This is the only component you can negotiate. Markups vary widely between processors, and this is where most pricing games happen.
Pricing Models Explained
Interchange-Plus (Best for Most)
You pay actual interchange + a fixed markup. Example: Interchange + 0.25% + $0.10.
Pros: Transparent, lowest total cost, you see exactly what you pay Cons: Monthly statements look complex (many line items)
Flat-Rate (Square, Stripe, etc.)
You pay one rate for everything. Example: 2.6% + $0.10 per transaction.
Pros: Simple, predictable, no monthly fees Cons: Overpay on most transactions, hidden markup built in
Tiered Pricing (Avoid!)
Transactions are sorted into "qualified," "mid-qualified," and "non-qualified" tiers.
Pros: None Cons: Processor controls which tier each transaction falls into, creates hidden markup
Why Flat-Rate Often Costs More
Flat-rate processors like Square advertise simplicity, but that simplicity has a cost. Here's an example:
A debit card transaction:
- Interchange: ~0.8% + $0.15
- Flat-rate price: 2.6% + $0.10
- Your overpayment: ~1.8%
On a $100 debit transaction, interchange is about $0.95. Square charges $2.70. That's $1.75 in hidden markup.
For low-volume businesses, flat-rate can make sense (no monthly fees). But once you're processing $10,000+/month, interchange-plus almost always saves money.
Hidden Fees to Watch For
PCI Compliance Fee
$99-$199/year charged for "helping" with PCI compliance. Often unnecessary—many processors include this.
Statement Fee
$10-$25/month for printing a statement. In 2024. Seriously.
Batch Fee
$0.25+ per day for "batching" your transactions. A made-up fee.
Minimum Monthly Fee
$25+ if you don't hit a processing minimum. Fair for small accounts, but should be clearly disclosed.
Early Termination Fee
$295-$495+ for canceling before your contract ends. Avoid contracts with ETFs.
Annual Fee
Random yearly charge with no clear purpose.
How to Lower Your Processing Costs
1. Know Your Effective Rate
Add up all fees and divide by total processing volume. If you're above 2.5%, you're likely overpaying.
2. Get a Statement Analysis
A good processor will analyze your current statements and show specific savings.
3. Negotiate the Markup
Interchange is fixed, but markup is negotiable. Ask for interchange + 0.2% + $0.08 or better.
4. Eliminate Junk Fees
Refuse PCI fees, statement fees, and batch fees. Good processors don't charge these.
5. Consider Cash Discount
Offset 100% of processing fees by offering a cash discount. Completely legal.
6. Use Proper Card Entry
Key-entered transactions cost more than swiped/dipped/tapped. Use the terminal.
7. Submit Transactions Quickly
Authorizations expire. Batch daily to avoid downgrades.
Bottom Line
Most businesses overpay on processing because they don't understand the fees. With interchange-plus pricing and a fair markup, you should be paying 1.8-2.3% all-in for a typical retail business.
If you're paying more, it's time to shop around.